|
|
||||||||
|
Boston College attracts praise and hostility for placing crucifixes in classrooms
![]() Related articles:
.- Crucifixes and icons were recently placed in all Boston College classrooms at the request of the Jesuit school’s president, Rev. William P. Leahy, SJ. The move has generated a variety of both enthusiastic and hostile responses. According to a statement from the Cardinal Newman Society (CNS), executive editor Donato Infante of the Boston College paper The Observer said that Father Leahy had employees hang the images in classrooms around campus over Christmas Break. Infante reported that during a “State of the Heights” address two weeks ago, Fr. Leahy responded to complaints about the imagery by saying that the administration did not need to consult professors about the decision. He insisted the crucifixes and the icons will not be taken down. Crucifixes and sacred art have had a scattered presence on campus since the 1970s, the CNS says. Two years ago, a new statue of the Society of Jesus’ founder St. Ignatius Loyola was erected on campus. Now there is a Catholic icon, usually a crucifix, above the lintel in all 151 college classrooms, the Boston Globe reports. Boston College spokesman Jack Dunn explained the increased presence of Christian images. According to the Boston Globe, Dunn said the art “reflects our pride in and commitment to our religious heritage.” The Boston Globe reports that student reaction has been generally supportive but faculty are divided. A January meeting of department chairs of the arts and sciences reportedly featured a heated argument over the images. A handful of faculty have written to the administration in protest, and some “unsuccessfully” circulated a petition asking to have the crucifixes removed. Maxim D. Shrayer, chairman of the department of Slavic and Eastern languages and literatures, told the Boston Globe that he believes the display of religious signs and symbols in the classroom is “contrary to the letter and spirit of open intellectual discourse that makes education worthwhile and distinguishes first-rate universities from mediocre and provincial ones.” In a statement published in the Observer, chemistry professor Amir H. Hoveyda attacked the decision, saying: “I can hardly imagine a more effective way to denigrate the faculty of an educational institution. If that has been the purpose of the administration of Boston College, I congratulate them, as they have succeeded brilliantly.” He argued that “such surface displays… belittle the significance of any symbol that pertains to any form of spirituality” Claiming that the classroom is “a symbol of dispensing with any prioritized prejudices,” he said the display of the crucifixes “represents a bias towards one way of thinking.” He charged the university administration’s approach with being “irresponsible and anti-intellectual.” “It is not how a progressive and enlightened university thinks and operates,” Prof. Hoveyda’s criticism continued, saying he had strongly believed in the principles of “freedom and tolerance and democracy” in his native Iran where he was imprisoned and “badly tortured” for those beliefs. “I am not about to give in now; I more than ever appreciate the importance of values that I, many of my colleagues and students stand for. As far as I could tell, such values were supposed to be part of the Jesuit tradition as well.” Fr. John Paris, SJ, was pleased with the display of the Christian imagery, saying to the Boston Globe “Christian iconography and symbols permeate this place and always have.” He said the notion that a crucifix impedes the ability of students or faculty to think critically was “offensive” to him and described such criticism as “the narrow and bizarre musings of a few disgruntled folks.” “This is a small problem for those with small minds," Paris continued, denying the issue is a serious controversy. The Observer quoted Boston College junior Michael Williams, who said “Although seemingly a small gesture, rest assured that these symbols give great joy and confidence to me and many of my friends for the direction the school is taking as becoming, as Father Leahy has put it, the nation's leading Catholic university.” CNS President Patrick J. Reilley also approved, saying “Bravo for Boston College!” “For Catholics, outward signs, symbols and practices of our faith are an important part of relating to God in a material world,” he said in a CNS statement. Reilley argued that the complaints are “a sad consequence of the mixed signals from Boston College over several years.” “At times Catholic teaching and tradition are celebrated, other times they are scorned and undermined. But the crucifixes are a very happy movement forward!” Infante asked critical professors to understand “what these symbols mean to us.” “The hanging of the sacred art had nothing to do with asserting power. It had everything to do with honoring our God and being constantly reminded of His love,” he said. Subscriber comments:
Published by: Michael Micik
Poughkeepsie NY 02/18/2009 01:04 PM EST
My son graduated from BC in May of 2008.
After visiting the campus many times during his four years there, I couldn't help but notice that it was a CATHOLIC college, run by a CATHOLIC priestly order !!!!!! If some of the left-leaning, atheistic faculty do not wish to recognize this fact, perhaps they should move onto more comfortable surroundings. God knows there are plenty of Godless colleges in this country !!!!!
Published by: Myron Moskowitz
Yardley,PA USA 02/14/2009 02:41 PM EST
At the age of 49 I converted to Catholicism from Judaism.I wish I knew the significance of the crucifix much earlier in my life.Fr. Leahy,God bless you.
Published by: Dr. William R. Luckey
Front Royal, VA, USA 02/14/2009 12:44 PM EST
Praise God for Father Leahey!!! Boston College has been the focal point for the struggle for Catholic identity in So-called Catholic universities for some time. Thank God someone in the Jesuit leadership has shown some guts at BC!
Published by: Fr. B
Claymont, Delaware 02/14/2009 09:49 AM EST
Truly good! I will no longer refer to BC as "barely Catholic" college. The crucifix on Good Friday was a small beginning; see where it has led.
Published by: Virgilijus Kaulius
Vancouver 02/14/2009 01:47 AM EST
Jesuit institutions by definition, should display religious symbolism, minimally the crucifix: why wasn't it from day ONE and only now?!!!
Any negative reaction to this move is a reaction against what the Jesuit Tradition of higher education stands for: cf. John O'Malley in "Companions" for a current short snipet of relevant history! Lastly, I resent the contemporary irrelevance and irreverence of citing some past personal life experience: so have we all! Torture wasn't invented in any one country: Christ Himself was tortured! Geeze, when will Professors get off their ego blindness and admit to the same core psychology resident in any one called "human?!" Chance favours the prepared mind!
Published by: Liz
Boston 02/14/2009 12:06 AM EST
The good news is that BC students and faculty and the wider community overwhelmingly support the Jesuits' right to display the crucifix on this Catholic campus. To those few who are offended: no one is forcing you to stay.
Published by: Dee
Boston, Ma 02/13/2009 11:09 PM EST
BRAVO TO BC!!!!!!!!!! Please do not let them take away Christian Symbols they have to understand (HELLOOOOOOOO)is a CATHOLIC INSTITUTION if they don't like to see the CRUCIFIXES they can go to another Institution to work or attend classes I believe no one is forced to work or to attend classes. GOD BLESS BC.
Published by: izzy
boston, ma 02/13/2009 10:45 PM EST
I'm not catholic. but it makes total sense for a Catholic school to display a Christian symbol. People, get over it. If you don't like it, go to a secular school. Little by little people's freedoms are being taken away. This is getting worse day by day. I don't like many things that people practice, but I don't go against it, so long as no one is being harmed in any way. Live & let live. Mind your own P&Q's
Published by: Julie Silva
Riverside, RI USA 02/13/2009 10:25 PM EST
Praise God! Let's celebrate our Catholic faith especially in a Catholic College. I hope other colleges take note.
God bless you, Father.
Published by: John Halbur
Joliet, IL, USA 02/13/2009 06:22 PM EST
Two thumbs up for Boston College! This is another blossom in the Springtime of faith that Pope John Paul II spoke about so eloquently. Let every Catholic College in the world follow suit, and then let them take it one step further by banning pro-"choice" speakers and professors, who make a mockery of the name Catholic.
If you object to crucifixes in the classroom, then consider the words of St, Padre Pio, the Franciscan priest who bore the bleeding wounds of Christ for 50 years, died in 1968, and was canonized in 2002: "The world could endure longer without the sun in the sky than it could without the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass". St. Pio's words are prophetic. Without Christ's sacrifice, which is symbolized by that crucifix and made present at every Mass, there would be no class, there would be no college, and there would be no humanity.
Published by: Jose
Arkansas 02/13/2009 04:51 PM EST
This is a no brainer. Catholic schools place crucifixes in their classrooms and buildings. If you don't like it, then work or go to school in our many secular institutions here in the U.S. Period!
Published by: Mary Teresa
Fairfax, Virginia 02/13/2009 04:40 PM EST
It seems that the crucifix has brought about the effect the Lord Jesus spoke of: "Do you think that I have come to give peace on earth? No, I tell you, but rather division;" [Luke 12:51]
The crucifix has brought to light those who love Him and those who fear/hate Him; those who are open to truth and those who want only their own brand of 'truth.' No such reactions are elicited by the Star of David, a woman in a burka, a Kwanzaa display, etc. Bravo Fr. Leahy!
Published by: Mark Sanford
Greenwich, Ct 02/13/2009 03:12 PM EST
How does The Crucifix impede academic freedom? Through history, some of greatest scientists and academics have been Catholic! These professors,have this dogma approach that anything that may lead or suggest a creator, should invalidated. How academic and scientific is that? May be these professors are ot really professors!
Published by: Chuck
Atlanta, Georgia, USA 02/13/2009 02:31 PM EST
Let's see..Catholic institution displaying Catholic symbols..Hum.. I do not see what is the issue here...
Published by: Fr Peter Calabrese
Lewisotn NY 02/13/2009 02:19 PM EST
Bravo to Fr Leahy and Boston College. The faculty opposed to this reveal their true colors when they feel that the crucifix is against truth. The Crucifix is an icon of the one Who is the TRUTH. Catholic scientific inquiry is true scientific inquiry not opposed to it. The Crucifix is the sign of real tolerance not the politically correct kind. What could be more tolerant that\n God dying on the cross.
Published by: Rose
IL 02/13/2009 02:15 PM EST
Jesus-God only holds everything together in the present Universe; why ever should He be acknowleged??
If ignoring Jesus in the modern world is "enlightenment" then count me out. Fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. People who pay to attend secular schools have become the dunces of society.
Published by: Lee Anders
Oswego, IL 02/13/2009 01:35 PM EST
The operative word is "Catholic". If "faculty members" don't like it they should be shown the door. My husband of happy memory would have said, "Don't let the door hit you in the ___ on the way out!!! Keep up the good work Father Leahy. We need more Jebs like YOU!!
Published by: John J. Fielding
Glen Cove, NY 02/13/2009 01:33 PM EST
Bravo for Boston College. In a world where symbolism is important this a good step in re-establishing a Catholic identity. Hopefully, more colleges will follow.
Published by: J Tool
Grand Rapids MI USA 02/13/2009 01:28 PM EST
I applaud the move to place Catholic symbols in every classroom. I attended a Catholic college and was disappointed to find no crucifix in every classroom. Though it was great to have a college math courses taught by a Sister start each day with a prayer.
Published by: David Jordan
Boston/Ma/USA 02/13/2009 01:07 PM EST
I think it has become a sad state of affairs when a Catholic college has to defend its use of religious art or symbols. I am a Catholic and attended Catholic schools all my life, I am 42 years old and what makes me wonder is how many people cannot look at the crucifix. To me it symbolizes Jesus's uncondtional sacrifice and love for humanity. And if certain faculty members or students find these images distracting and personally insulting, quit your job and or attend another school!
Published by: Anthony
Saginaw MI 02/13/2009 12:33 PM EST
This is great. There shouldn't even have been the question of whether or not crucifixes should be placed in the classtooms, they should have been there from the beginning. It's a Catholic college. I just think those critical faculty members need to get over themselves.
Published by: Lisa
Westfield, MA 02/13/2009 12:10 PM EST
I am very happy to hear that the students are appreciative of the return of crucifixes to the classrooms at BC. The comments of the student who said that it gave him and his friends "great joy and confidence" was heartening to read. The comments of the professors who are upset by this are bizarre in the extreme. Why is it that "tolerance" always means "everything but Christianity"?? Bravo, BC, bravo! We have to ask ourselves, in situations like this - who do we respect more - God? Or Public Opinion?
Published by: Tom
oh 02/13/2009 11:40 AM EST
What a wonderful move on the part of Rev. Leahy! Thank you!
Published by: Mary
Maple Hill, KS, USA 02/13/2009 11:38 AM EST
Praise the Lord! Is this not a Catholic college? Why should the school hide its identity? Cudos to Fr. Leahy! If professors are complaining about the Catholicity, get replacements. I'm sure that you could find qualified professors.
Published by: Chuck
Atlanta Georgia 02/13/2009 11:26 AM EST
Now let's see. Catholic institution displaying Catholic symbols. I do not see what is the problem..
Published by: Michele
So Cal 02/13/2009 10:50 AM EST
I can't believe anyone would complain about Catholic symbols being hung in a Catholic school. If Catholics don't want to see symbols of their faith, they should examine if they're really Catholic. For non-Catholics who have issues with it, no one forced them to go to a Catholic school. Would you walk into a friend's house and insist on changing the decor?
Published by: Mrs. Thompson
Ann Arbor/MI/USA 02/13/2009 10:46 AM EST
Bravo! It's about time Catholic colleges stop being afraid of what they are - Catholic - and start embracing it. Any professor who is uncomfortable around a crucifix might want to reconsider teaching somewhere else!! Thank you Father Leahy for doing what was right.
Published by: ed
milford, nh, usa 02/13/2009 10:05 AM EST
Would these same professors demand that the Star of David or menorah be removed from schools or Universities with a Jewish religious identity?
Never! The stalking horse for anti-Catholics trots on.
Published by: Bill Sr.
Jacksonville, FL 02/13/2009 10:04 AM EST
I tried to send the following to Prof. Hoveyda at the e-mail address noted for him but it bounced off.
I can understand the sight of our Lord on the cross right there in your classroom might distress you. When we think that he actually chose to allow himself to be treated in such a manner for the sake of mankind. It must have been a truly gruesome sight for his followers and especially his own mother. And knowing that the selfish acts of pride and prejudice of each of us were in truth part of the burden he carried with him to that cross. That's enough to distress anyone. But the Lord carried something else with him to the cross. Something that is nearly beyond our human capability to understand. Something that gives hope to the whole world and allows us to be filled with compassion for all peoples. He lifted the Love of God for all humanity with him upon that cross. A love so strong and so pure and so deep that it did not matter how great the shame or enigma the appearance on the cross his accusers had desired for him this Love for you and me and even those who were torturing him would overshadow and obliterate it. Once we accept this fact of life for the human race the knowledge, the understanding, and the physical presence of mind the crucifix offers us helps to remind us of not only the secular or historical nature of the greatest of all love stories but also it gives us the courage and determination to add our own personal efforts and accomplishments to the
Published by: Nick
Palatine, IL, U.S.A. 02/13/2009 09:56 AM EST
I find it highly probable that the reason for such revulsion amongst some of the professors, is the fact that they will so visibly be watched over by our Savior as they try to brain-wash America's youth. Good for you Boston College; I have been rather critical of the Jesuits in past years, but I have seen a number of promissing changes that show some of them reahing back to their past greatness. Keep up the good work.
Published by: Noel Cordero
Bronx, New York USA 02/13/2009 09:54 AM EST
Fordham University can learn much from this, IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE A CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY!! HELLO! HOPEFULLY FORDHAM UNIVERSITY WILL AS WELL PLACE CRUCIFIXES ETC IN EVERY CLASSROOM.
Published by: Bart Trudeau, AIA
Latham, NY 02/13/2009 09:25 AM EST
May God bless you Rev. William P. Leahy, SJ and all of your faculty and students who support the notion that a symbol of love and truth is most appropriate in a room for learning.
Published by: Myles Keogh
Fort Riley Kansas 02/13/2009 08:56 AM EST
BRAVO TO BC!!!! Last time I checked BC was a CATHOLIC INSTITUTION. If these "educators" don't like the fact that they work for a university founded and governed as a CATHOLIC INSTITUTION then they should go find employment elsewhere.
Published by: Dan
Santa Fe/NM/US 02/13/2009 07:51 AM EST
I think Reilley got it right--This college and many others have celebrated Catholicism's 'Universal' nature thinking that means to embrace all thinking including the secular. Catholicism is rooted in Christ and yes that is without a doubt a 'bias toward one way of thinking'. It seems like a great way to flush out those who have contrary 'values' whatever that means, as those opposed seem to talk the vague language of secularism. Maybe this can act as a learning experience for these so called learned academic professors that sound like they should have been required to be educated on Catholicm before they were hired to teach their nameless 'values' to our young adults. I feel bad for the man who believes icons are similar to torture however this man and his views should not be teaching anyone let alone students at a Catholic University.
Published by: Madeleine Veneklase
Holt, MI 02/13/2009 05:59 AM EST
There is no time better than the present moment to affirm our faith in Christ. What true Christian individual or institution can remain silent now, when unbelievers everywhere scream? God the Father Spoke His Word. I greatly respect BC and the Jesuits for lifting high the cross!
ADD A COMMENT (Your e-mail will NOT be published):
* Thanks for your comments. The number of messages that can be online is limited. Length should not exceed 1500 characters. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages. ADVERTISING |
Latest news:
03:07 pm | Spouse of Costa Rican presidential candidate 'pockets' Eucharist 02:15 pm | Vatican responds to widely divergent reports on Boffo resignation 12:56 pm | Venezuelan cardinal calls for new evangelization of country's capital 11:11 am | International congress to focus on priestly identity and celibacy 07:10 am | Former Saints star says Super Bowl victory revealed a ‘team with destiny’ Related news :
St. Thomas More College announces 'Faith & Reason' scholarship contest State to take over Catholic College of Santa Fe Thomas Aquinas College celebrates placement of cornerstone blessed by the Pope Get CNA News on your email:
Resources
|
ADVERTISING
Place your ad here |
||||||
|
||||||||

