Cardinal Mahony implores Supreme Court to keep priest files confidential, cites 1st Amendment, confessional freedoms
Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest Addthis

.- Cardinal Roger Mahony and the lawsuit-wracked Archdiocese of Los Angeles have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to overrule a series of lower court decisions, and protect the Archdiocese’s constitutional right to keep priest files confidential.

Fourteen files from Archdiocesan priests accused of sexual abuse are in question, all of which, the Church argues, the courts should not have access to.

It’s the latest step for the Church in Los Angeles fighting to block a subpoena from L.A. district attorney Steve Cooley, who wants to use the private files--some of which contain private penitential conversations--as legal testimony.

In a Los Angeles Times editorial, Erik Berkowitz, a LA writer and lawyer, said that while the Archdiocese is fighting an uphill battle, a loss mean be “a step backward” for justice.

“In prying open the church's files,” he wrote, “the courts also will be trampling on some of society's most important constitutional and civil rights — including the Catholic Church's 1st Amendment right to freely exercise its religion and an individual's right to discuss sins in private with clergy.”

“Ironically,” he added, “the courts might even be making it harder for religious organizations to prevent abuse by priests” in the future.

While many question the way that Cardinal Mahony has handled the scandal, Berkowitz said that this “doesn't mean we should hinder his successors from trying to do a better job.”

“Yet”, he explained, “that is exactly what the courts will do if they force these documents into the light.”

Priest-penitent seal 

Question about the priest-penitent seal and private discussions in the confessional have also stepped into the foreground recently, particularly in Los Angeles and in other parts of the country, most notably, New Hampshire where a newly proposed bill could require priests to divulge information about sexual abuse—even if it was obtained in the confessional.

On this, Berkowitz pointed out that “As with the attorney-client and psychotherapist-patient privileges, the protection of clergy-penitent communications expresses society's collective decision that it is more important to guard a confidential relationship than it is to expose what happened in a particular case.”

“For many,” he wrote, “the ability to communicate freely with their clergy serves the same function as psychotherapy. We may not see much value in providing this service to accused child molesters, but when the privilege is weakened for some people, it is weakened for all of us. Such communications are generally inviolate, even if they include admissions of criminal wrongdoing.”

Under Church practice, the bishop acts as primary counsel and many times, confessor, for the priests working under him.

Recently, another Los Angeles court, in a related case, ordered Msgr. Michael Lenihan, an Archdiocesan priest, to reveal whether a transitional deacon, accused of sexual abuse, came to him for confession.

Canon Law and Church experts decried the act as a blatant violation of the priest-penitent relationship--legally binding throughout the country--and demanded that the court withdraw the request.

Richard Thomson, Chief Counsel for the Michigan-based Thomas More Law Center, told the National Catholic Register that as Catholics, “our feeling is that the confessional seal is inviolable, no matter what the court says.”

He lamentably added that “People want to use the emotion of the sexual scandals to try to break down the sanctity of confession.”

Ads by AdsLiveMedia(What's this?)

* The number of messages that can be online is limited. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages


Ads by Google (What's this?)
Ads by Google

Featured Videos

Little Sisters of the Poor press conference in Denver
Little Sisters of the Poor press conference in Denver
Family thrilled to see Pope Francis in Istanbul
Syrian Refugee, Sara, 14, Before Meeting Pope
Ebola orphans thousands of children in West Africa
One year after Haiyan: Philippines rebuilds homes, lives
An Indian contribution to the Vatican's Synod on the Family
Christ Cathedral CNA video Sept 2014
Alejandro Bermudez of CNA accepts ice bucket challenge
'The Real Albania,' remembering those who fled
Pope Francis in Albania, "one of the most important visits of the post-communist era in Albania"
Pope Francis greets paralyzed man who risked all to see him
Franciscans on the banks of the Tiber in Rome, working for the New Evangelization
Pilgrimage from Czech Republic to Assisi and Rome for intentions
Testimony of young Indian who met Pope in Korea
Preparations of the Closing Mass of 6th Asian Youth Day
Missionary of Charity, Korea
Testimony of Christian Love during Pope's Visit to Korea
Religious Sisters in South Korea react to Pope Francis kissing a baby
Warm atmosphere during Holy Mass at Daejeon World Cup Stadium
Images inside Pope Francis flight to South Korea

Liturgical Calendar

December 18, 2014

Advent Weekday

All readings:
Today »
This year »

Catholic Daily

Gospel of the Day

Mt 21:23-27


Daily Readings

First Reading:: Jer 23: 5-8
Gospel:: Mt 1: 18-25

Saint of the Day

St. Romuald »


Homily of the Day

Mt 21:23-27