Fargo Bishop addresses the roots of dissent among Catholics in pastoral letter
Imprimir Incrementar tamaño de fuente Disminuir tamaño de fuente

.- In a pastoral letter to be released on Saturday, Most Rev. Samuel J. Aquila, Bishop of Fargo, addresses the roots of dissent among Catholics, highlighted during the recent elections in the U.S., and picks out five main areas of concern.

In his letter, entitled “"You Will Know the Truth and the Truth Will Set You Free" A Pastoral Letter on Deepening our Understanding of the Truths of the Catholic Faith,” Bishop Aquila notes that many Catholics “are more influenced by the secular culture in which we live than by the teachings of Jesus Christ,” and stated that many Catholics have “an inadequate understanding of the Catholic faith.”

He suggests that though there are exceptions, catechetical formation for the last 30 years has failed to hand on the faith. He says it was clear during the media discussion of Catholic teachings and voting during the elections that “many of the faithful have not read the Catechism, the encyclicals of Pope John Paul II, or the documents of Vatican II.”

Accepting Church teaching

The first area of concern is that many people who call themselves Catholic “even reject the principle that we must accept what the Church believes and teaches, and think they can pick and choose what to believe,” writes the bishop.

“We must never forget that certain Church teachings,” - those revealed in Scripture and Apostolic Tradition and upheld by the Magisterium – “can never change,” he said, “regardless of whether or not people accept them or are faithful to them.”

Only Jesus Christ sets us free

Noting that secular culture exposes Catholics to “a variety of ideas that are incompatible with the truths of faith,” and that “Christians are by no means immune to these influences but adopt elements of them without recognizing their incompatibility with Christian faith,” the bishop stresses that “we must become more deeply convinced that we can find the truth that sets us free only in Jesus Christ.”

These secularist influences have a produced a culture of death where abortion and euthanasia are regarded by many as a “right,” promoted by the media and publicly funded, he notes.

He notes that if we make moral decisions according to the culture of death “we form our character in a way that is incompatible with the authentic fulfillment that God so much wants us to receive,” and that we must learn how to choose correctly.

Understanding conscience correctly

Bishop Aquila points to the crisis in the understanding of conscience, saying that  “Catholics sometimes say they are following their conscience when they choose to do something-for example, tell a lie, use contraception, have or recommend abortion, defraud someone, conceive a child through in vitro fertilization-that the Church teaches to be intrinsically evil.”

“Our conscience-our last and best judgment about what morality concretely requires-can be mistaken,” he says. “Pastors must clarify what conscience is, show the faithful how to recognize an erroneous conscience, and help them form their conscience properly.”

He notes that the guidance given the faithful by some members of the clergy to “Just follow your conscience," is misleading without proper explanation “because it suggests that people are responsibly following their conscience when they knowingly replace Christ's teaching with the world's opinions.”

Appreciating the dignity of human life

The bishop states that the dignity of human life is not sufficiently appreciated by Catholics who “all too often regard abortion and euthanasia primarily as political issues on which they can legitimately take a position at odds with the teachings of Christ and his Church. “

“Practices like abortion and euthanasia are morally abhorrent even when they are called "rights" and given the protection of law.  They remain abhorrent even when such a law is agreed upon by a majority of persons,” he says. 

He also points out that the “tendency among some Catholics to equate all issues of life such that, for example, capital punishment and war are considered to have the same moral significance as abortion and euthanasia,” are “misguided.”

Faith is not private

“We must deepen our understanding of what it means to live out our faith in the world,” writes Bishop Aquila. He points out that Catholics who say they are personally opposed to abortion “but defend the alleged right to abortion and even approve when others choose it”… separate their personal conviction about fundamental truths from their public life.”

“Whether they are culpable or not, such persons cooperate in a grave evil by their support of abortion,” he writes and affirms that “Catholic politicians who vote specifically to fund abortions do not merely cooperate with a grave evil but are principal agents in a grave evil.”

“All too often,” he states, “Catholic public officials and voters are more deeply committed to their political agendas than they are to the teaching of Christ.” 

In concluding Bishop Aquila points to other serious areas of confusion that need to be addressed: “the assumption that salvation is universal and automatic no matter what one says or does; the failure to celebrate the Sacrament of Reconciliation on a regular basis and to be properly disposed before receiving Holy Communion; the failure to appreciate the truth, dignity, and meaning of human sexuality; the failure to understand the apostolic authority of bishops; and pastoral practices in dioceses which go beyond legitimate diversity.”

Imprimir Incrementar tamaño de fuente Disminuir tamaño de fuente
Subscriber comments:
Published by: Bruce
Wilmington, DE, USA 09/16/2008 10:20 AM EST
Bravo! We are 'standing in the face...' as late JPII said before taking papal office.
Published by: james cole
europe 06/19/2005 12:36 AM EST
Hello, i will like to make donation to your organisation. how will like wire the money to you.
pls reply soon.
james
Published by: MRS. ROSEMARIE HENN
WASILLA,, ALASKA USA 04/14/2005 09:19 PM EST
PRAISE GOD. BISHOP AQUILA TAKES HIS OFFICE OF SHEPHERD SERIOULY. HE GUIDES AND NURTURES HIS FLOCK. GOD WILLING OTHER SHEPHERDS WILL TAKE COURAGE IN THIS TROUBLED TIME AND GUIDE THEIR FLOCKS IN THE WAY THE TRUTH AND THE LIFE. AMEN
Rosemarie Henn
Published by: art crosetti
pleasanton, ca 94566 usa 01/17/2005 11:41 AM EST
Thanks for printing that clear unequivocal message by the bishop.Given the moral crisis in our country the passiveness and silence of church authority on these issues is quite frankly scandalous.

Art Crosetti
Published by: Raymond
TN 01/10/2005 02:48 PM EST
I would like to add a response from my e-mail on the 7th.... Bishop Aquila, there is an old saying that the laity get the clergy they deserve. I would like to add that the USCCB gets the laity that they have so pastorally and paternally led for the past 40 years, and hence the laity and dissesion they deserve.
Published by: Jerry Smolynsky
Chicago IL 01/09/2005 03:23 PM EST
Thanks for this excellent article. However, each time I try to email this article to others there seems to be a techical problem in which another article about Billy Graham on the Passion of Christ is sent. This happens on the printable link also. Thank you.
Published by: Jurate P Field
Huntington Beach, CA USA 01/09/2005 12:11 PM EST
Yes, and it is you, the
Bishops of the USA who have made the Catholic who he is today. My own
Bishop won't allow 1hr a week for a Tridentine Mass for the sake of 'unity'. Imagine, the 'Sacrifice' 'destroying unity';gotta lov' it!
Published by: John Quirk
Anchorage, AK 01/07/2005 11:37 PM EST
We need to pray every day that our Bishops and Priests will be leaders and not followers of those among us who are following the world. If the Holy Spirit could take 12 unlearned men and start our Church-certainly the highly educated leaders should make it an easy task for the Holy Spirit, if they will pray and listen to him. JMJ
Published by: Raymond
TN 01/07/2005 03:15 PM EST
I commend the bishop for his pastoral letter. I wish the same would happen in our diocese. I do regret that he didn't address other issues contributing to dissent. Those issues come from the church itself. When the "American Catholic Church" hierarchy is corrupt, indifferent, on the verge of schism what does he expect of the laity? For the past 40 years, Catholics have been told that everything that they held dear and the liturgy they loved and the devotions that they had were suspect at best and irrelevent at worst. People no longer have the fortitude to endure the leftover love-children of the 60s running the way they believe and worship. Just a view from the pew, but I and many like me are just tired of it all. My suggestion to Bishop Aquilla is to tell his "brothers" to just let us be Catholic and we will come back. Then he won't have to worry about the "dissenters".
Published by: Philomena Dunkl
Charlottesville, VA USA 01/06/2005 02:25 PM EST
Although Bishop Aquila correctly identifies the roots of dissent among Catholics, the concluding paragraph contributes to the confusion. Orthodox Catholics often find their bishops opposing the teachings of the Church and endorsing "pastoral practices that go beyond legitimate diversity". Until the bishops accept and then reaffirm the Catholic faith and the teachings of the Church, lay Catholics will make incorrect choices based on incorrectly and misformed consciences. The bishops should be held accountable for failing to hand on the faith. As a mother of two children now in their 30s who were raised in the Diocese of Richmond for all their formative years, I know first hand how the Church failed this generation. (For example, my first child was not introduced to the Sacrament of Reconciliation before her First Communion and she was never encouraged to receive of this sacrament in any religious education program.)

Sincerely,
Philomena R. Dunkl, Ph.D.
ADD A COMMENT (Your e-mail will NOT be published):
NAME:
CITY/STATE/COUNTRY:
EMAIL:
COMMENT:
 
PLEASE ENTER THE SECURITY CODE DISPLAYED ABOVE:
Chars:
* Thanks for your comments. The number of messages that can be online is limited. Length should not exceed 1500 characters. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages.
Latest news:
Get CNA News on your email:
Your E-mail:
Subscribe HTML
Unsubscribe Text only
Headlines
Resources
read this
First Reading:
rss
read this
podcast
audio
Gospel:
rss
read this
podcast
audio
Saint of the Day
podcast
audio
Homily of the day
ADVERTISING
Place your ad here
Resources:
Columns:
News:
Documents:
Tools:
ACI Group:
ACI Prensa