PBS national board bans new religious programming, including Mass for Shut-ins
Imprimir Incrementar tamaño de fuente Disminuir tamaño de fuente

Cardinal Sean O'Malley celebrates Mass on camera

.- The members of PBS’ national board have voted to ban any new religious programming from their affiliate stations, citing both concerns about “public trust” and a 25-year-old rule that has never been rigorously enforced. Anticipation of the vote already resulted in one station cancelling its Mass for Shut-Ins.

The 1985 rule in question requires PBS affiliates to air only non-commercial, non-partisan and non-sectarian content.

Reportedly six affiliates broadcast “sectarian” programs produced by local religious groups, such as the Mass for Shut-Ins. These affiliates may retain their current shows and air programs and documentaries that cover sacred or newsworthy topics, Fox News says.

However, no new religious shows can be offered, and the 350 other stations may not air any purely spiritual content.

PBS affiliate WHUT in Washington, D.C. had already decided to end its 13 year tradition of broadcasting a weekly Mass to avoid violating membership rules.

“This is community-based, locally produced programming that fills a community need,” Susan Gibbs, director of Communications for the Catholic Archdiocese of Washington, told Fox News.

The Archdiocese of Washington has agreed to pay $60,000 to air its Mass for Shut-Ins on another network.

"PBS is respecting that there is a history of programming," Gibbs added. "It's unfortunate it's not going to continue for us."

Ron Yager, general manager of New Orleans affiliate WLAE, said the station was “very satisfied” that the shut-ins and the home-bound among its viewers can continue to view the daily Mass, which he said was “vital” to them.

KBDI president and CEO Wick Rowland described his station as “very eclectic” with a “huge diversity” of programming, which for a decade has included a weekly Mass.

“No one would mistake us for Catholic television station,” he told Fox News.

PBS affiliate KBYU in Utah is run by Brigham Young University and airs Mormon devotionals. Its managing director Derek Marquis said he was “pleased” by the decision, which he said would allow the station to provide both national PBS content and locally produced content “reflective of the values and mission” of the university.

Federal law does not bar showing religious services on public television. However, the PBS Station Services Committee voiced concerns the broadcast would create the appearance of an official endorsement and “would cause the public's trust in PBS to erode, along with the value of the brand.”

The PBS committee, composed of representatives of local networks, reviewed the network’s bylaws and authored the compromise.

CNA contacted the U.S. Conference for Catholic Bishops’ Communications Office for a reaction to the decision but did not receive a response by press time.

Imprimir Incrementar tamaño de fuente Disminuir tamaño de fuente
Subscriber comments:
Published by: Richard Lee Dechert
Maplewood, MN 06/22/2009 04:52 PM EST
The PBS board did NOT "ban any new religious programming," sectarian or nonsectarian, from PBS stations. The Catholic News Agency (CNA) and other media failed to carefully review the updated PBS requirement on religious programming, summarized in the 6/16/09 posting on "Current," a public broadcasting newspaper:

"In a compromise with the small number of PBS stations running religious programming, the PBS board today approved a membership requirement that would allow those shows to continue but would ban more sectarian programs to be added on PRIMARY channels. Also, religious programs may be carried on MULTICAST [SECONDARY] channels or OTHER PLATFORMS as long as PBS branding is not included...." [Emphases added]

So, in my understanding of the requirement, PBS digital stations can provide Catholic and other church services on their MULTICAST [SECONDARY] channels if they aren't PBS branded, and their Websites can also be a PLATFORM for services if they aren't branded.

That cannot be credibly characterized as religious bias or censorship. Moreover, the CNA and other media failed to clearly note that PBS stations will still provide a wide range of nonsectarian programs, with the award-winning "Religion & Ethics Newsweekly" being one of many examples.

Richard Lee Dechert,
a retired PBS station staffer
Published by: Zach
Washington, DC 06/21/2009 11:08 AM EST
It's a publicly funded station. What about those of us who don't believe in God or religion? Don't worry, folks - the priests are still on the major networks.
Published by: dAVID LARSEN
scituate Mass 06/21/2009 03:10 AM EST
The public broadcasting system is to serve the public that sends them donations so they can stay on the air. Secular humanistic secular viewpoints are neutral and ultimately no viewpoint at all about much of anything,so it is relative thinking.
Religious viewpoints are driving forces for both good and evil that has been happening in our times. Many people have strong faith beliefs rational and irrational. These belief systems must be presented in these days as we need to all understand each other better. The more that religion is driven from public thought the greater it becomes,as it then goes "Underground"and becomes irrational and a source for violence or as well an unheard or suppressed voice appealing for reason,that is very rational.
The Catholic Mass is innocence in action that appeals to the forces for reason.
Secular humanism is relativism in action,it is like communism and also like it's grandfather fascism,it is thinking that suppresses all free and reasonable thinking. Usually what happens when any society aggressively decides to suppress all religious belief systems and customs,it simply falls apart and eventually dies.
Send not a cent to PBS. They are NOT OBJECTIVE THEY ARE SUBJECTIVE AND SECULARLY,LIBERALLY CONTROLLED VIEWPOINTS for the "PUBLIC VIEWING.
Published by: martie
Akron, OH, USA 06/20/2009 11:58 AM EST
I wonder what prompted the PBS board to enforce a rule that has been ignored for so long?
Yes, there are religious stations but many people don't have cable and , therefore, can't access them. PBS is for the people and paid for by the people. Not every program is going to satisfy every viewer but we value the programs that we like.
The lady who inferred that the Mormons are followers of Satan might do well to examine her own state of mind and remember that only God is to judge others by their faith and actions.
Published by: Anne
C 06/20/2009 09:29 AM EST
Unfortunately,the liberal affect and effect in our country is at the fault of voters. All voters need to take responsibility and realize this is what you get. I have heard so many people say how sorry they are they voted for Obama. What did they expect?.
Published by: M. A. Kay
Fairlawn, OH 06/19/2009 04:13 PM EST
I am so glad that I heard about this before I sent my local PBS station my yearly contribution. I will instead send it to EWTN.
Published by: john Madia
elria, oh 06/19/2009 01:51 PM EST
One less organization to donate to--It's a real shame you decided not to tele. Mass to shut ins. A shame award to you!!!!!!
Published by: jack smith
cartersville/ga/usa 06/19/2009 08:51 AM EST
Well, I can take my donation and give it to some worth while organization (notPBS) and I urge you all to do the same.....
Published by: d.smith
calif 06/18/2009 09:21 PM EST
News item: The public's trust in PBS has just eroded - along with trust in the "value of the brand." Another situation of one-sidedness flooding our national scene.

Those who would restrict religion in our country don't have to do much before even PBS folds at the knees.

We used to trust PBS over the other networks because of its integrity.
Published by: A jaime
Shaker Heights OH 06/18/2009 08:46 PM EST
I am very disappointed in how the PBS committee used "OUR Public trust" being eroded to jusitfy the erroneous reason to stop airing "CATHOLIC" services for the shut-ins... It's sad.
I will be not support PBS until they are fair - THIS COUNTRY WAS BASED IN A CHRISTIAN FAITH ... while respecting all others.
Published by: Claudia Schumacher
Gilbert, AZ USA 06/18/2009 07:22 PM EST
This is religious discrimination of the worse kind! You can be sure that PBS will not be obtaining any contributions on my part!
Published by: Robert
Santa Barbara Ca. U.S.A. 06/18/2009 06:36 PM EST
How sad,They have programming about homosexuality,but no more Mass for shutins.
Published by: Meg Noethen
Fairlawn, OH 06/18/2009 04:46 PM EST
I am tired of US schools,agencies and private entities perpetuating "freedom from religion" instead of "freedom of religion". I'm a Catholic but have enjoyed hearing programming by protestant, Jewish and Muslim people. NPR expressly states that the opinions are not those of the radio station. I see no violation of the public trust.
Published by: Mary
usa 06/18/2009 04:34 PM EST
I don't suppose they will take Wayne Dyer and other newage gurus off.
Published by: Linda Benedetti
Copley, OH USA 06/18/2009 03:52 PM EST
With all the evil in this world you keep the violent shows on the air the pull positive programming. I guess it all comes down to the money; doesn't it. Oh well, everyone will face their judgement day and you will have to be judged on the actions you take. I wish you luck.
Published by: Joseph Vazzo
TulsA OK USA 06/18/2009 03:39 PM EST
This is what happens when a
federal government, taxpayer
supported organization feels the need to provide entertainment for the public.
Rather than cut back on spiritual programming, an effort should be made to provide something for all faiths. If this is impossible, the organization needs to
be eliminated as it is another
government intrusion into private enterprise. Know if
the Congress and Courts decide it is acceptable, such
a media outlet could become
a government propaganda
machine.
Published by: Polly Dobkin
Akron, OH USA 06/18/2009 03:19 PM EST
What a sad state of affairs that you will not broadcast a religious program to shut-ins. I am not Roman Catholic and feel very bad for those who wish to watch mass will be unable to do so. God is with us always and those who are unable to get out should be permitted to watch a Mass or other religious program on TV. No one states that you must watch these programs, it should be a matter of choice.
Published by: Hank Lindner
Memphis, TN, USA 06/18/2009 01:46 PM EST
I thought it was Public Broadcasting? Our religion is public not private so why shouldn't it be broadcast. Our funds pay for all of it so it should include us, the public.
Published by: His Prince Michael
Avon, CO 06/18/2009 01:36 PM EST
Got CHANGE?
Published by: Constance
CT, USA 06/18/2009 01:14 PM EST
This is another attack on Catholicism. They took a "rule" out of the dusty closet to do this. Even CEO Wick Rowland doesn't seem to have a problem with airing a Mass.

It is sad how the PBS KBYU is pleased by this decision, yet will air Mormon (religious) devotionals.

Satan is having his way. This will hurt many who can't get to Mass.
Published by: Dennis Dreyer
Fennville, Michigan USA 06/18/2009 01:02 PM EST
“would cause the public's trust in PBS to erode, along with the value of the brand.”

Are you joking? PBS is biased and at best a brand for liberal statists.

With all of the communications stations available to us today, why should our tax dollars go to funding any "public" stations?
Published by: Julie Silva
Riverside, RI USA 06/18/2009 01:01 PM EST
This is a sad time for our country. I never will support PBS again not that I do it that often. I do get mail from them though and I will let them know about this decision.
Published by: homer ice
norwood, ohio, usa 06/18/2009 12:51 PM EST
Christians should not give any money to PBS because PBS shows programs which teach evolution.
Published by: George Alexa
Fairfax Station, VA 06/18/2009 12:42 PM EST
Sitting in the outmail was my check which was supposed to go out three days ago! I'm happy that it didn't go out! I will think twice about supporting PBS from now on!
Published by: Jeanne
La Palma, CA USA 06/18/2009 11:19 AM EST
We have the Catholic network that has daily Mass and other fine Catholic programs 24/7. PBS claims their rules have been violated for a long time. That's wrong and shouldn't have been allowed for any reason.
#
Published by: Jerome
Chicago, IL 06/18/2009 11:04 AM EST
GOOD. Religious programming/content should NOT be on public TV/radio.
Published by: Bill Sr.
Jacksonville FL 06/18/2009 10:30 AM EST
With the liberals in complete control of every branch of the government.....what else would you expect????
Get use to it.. there's lots more coming now that we are "no longer a Christian nation" as pronounced by our great leader whom we as Catholics have had the "privilege of honoring".
Published by: Dan
Santa Fe/NM/US 06/18/2009 09:26 AM EST
If Catholics voted and acted as a group this would not be an issue---PBS would bend over backwards. As usual it's the fault of those claiming to be card carrying Catholics but who live a secular, and now, an anti-Catholic life. Shame on them.
Published by: Leanne
Fredericksburg/VA/USA 06/18/2009 07:39 AM EST
I continue to be baffled by the premise that in order to demonstrate that an organization is not religious, all non-secular elements must be purged. Freedom of religion does not mean freedom from religion.
ADD A COMMENT (Your e-mail will NOT be published):
NAME:
CITY/STATE/COUNTRY:
EMAIL:
COMMENT:
 
PLEASE ENTER THE SECURITY CODE DISPLAYED ABOVE:
Chars:
* Thanks for your comments. The number of messages that can be online is limited. Length should not exceed 1500 characters. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages.
ADVERTISING
Place your ad here
Resources:
Columns:
News:
Documents:
Tools:
ACI Group:
ACI Prensa