|
|
||||||||
|
Legion of Christ responds to founder's alleged children
![]() Father Marcial Maciel, the late founder of the Legion of Christ.
Related articles:
.- The Legionaries of Christ released two statements today responding to the dramatic revelations by a woman and her three sons who claim to be the wife and children of Fr. Marcial Maciel. During an interview in front of a large television audience in Mexico, Blanca Estela Lara Gutiérrez and her sons charged that Fr. Maciel, the founder of the Legion of Christ, led a parallel life. The interview coincided with a visit to Mexico made by Father Álvaro Corcuera L.C., currently the director of the Legion of Christ. During the interview, Lara Gutiérrez said that she met Fr. Maciel in 1970, when she was 19 years old. Maciel was 56 at the time. He told her that his name was “Raúl Rivas” and that he was a widower. Though they never officially married, Lara Gutiérrez said that Fr. Maciel had two children her and adopted a third whom she had from a previous relationship. The children were registered as Omar, José Raúl, y Cristian González Lara. During the long interview, which was rebroadcast in Spanish on Thursday by CNN for viewers in Latin America, the three children gave intensely dramatic details about how they were sexually abused as children by “Raúl Rivas.” They also spoke of how they came to know their father’s real identity and how they reacted to the accusations presented to the Holy See against Fr. Maciel. At the end of the program, the González Lara family demanded the attention both of the Legionaries and of the Vatican. In reaction to the interview, Jim Fair, spokesman for the Legion in the United States told CNA that he was “shocked and disappointed. But the Legion wants to act responsibly, get to the bottom of things and correct what needs to be corrected.” On Thursday, the Legion of Christ in Mexico released two simultaneous statements through which they expressed their pain and solidarity with Fr. Maciel’s alleged family, though they neither confirmed nor denied the allegations. The statements also revealed that Raúl González, who has been acting as the spokesperson for the family, has previously requested $26 million from the Legion in exchange for not breaking the story. The first statement said that the Legionaries “share the suffering and pain of the members of the González Lara family, understanding the difficult circumstances they have lived and are living.” “In recent years, the Legionaries of Christ have gradually come to know, with surprise and great sorrow, hidden aspects of the life of Fr. Maciel. We confirm our commitment to act in truth and charity. We renew our request for forgiveness from the affected people for all of the suffering this has caused and for the ensuing scandal,” added the statement. The same statement made public a letter that Fr. Carlos Skertchly, L.C. wrote to Raúl González Lara on January 12, 2010. “At this time, it is impossible for Fr. Álvaro Corcuera to come to Mexico to meet with you as you requested, so he asked me as his representative to be available to meet with you and listen to you,” Fr. Skertchly informed him in the letter. “Our intention as members of the congregation of the Legionaries of Christ is to do whatever is possible to uncover the truth about our founder’s life, to look for the best solutions—in a spirit of gospel charity—to the complex situations that are presenting themselves, and to reach out pastorally to all of the people who have suffered or who may be affected by it.” Fr. Skertchly also recounted his interaction with Raúl González Lara, writing, “On January 8 in the afternoon, I received your phone call, in which you confirmed your request, affirming that ‘if you give me the money ($26 million), I will keep quiet about the truth,’ and you asked for a response by January 13 at the latest,” the letter continues. “In no way can we accede to your request for money in exchange for silence. While we value all of the pain and suffering that you have shared with us, and we deplore the evil of scandal that may follow, we will never accept petitions of this sort, which are also illicit. We prefer to seek and face the truth, no matter how painful it may be,” affirmed Fr. Skertchly. In the second statement, Fr. Jesús Quirce Andrés, L.C., rector of Anáhuac University, who was mentioned by the González Lara family in the interview, stated that he been involved in conversations with Raúl González at Gonzalez’s request beginning on April 18, 2008. Raúl had presented himself to the university, requesting to speak “with someone in authority.” “At the beginning of October of 2008, he told me that his father had mentioned that his will was to leave a legacy of $6 million for Raúl, his younger brother, and his mother,” said Fr. Andrés. “He never told me that he had been abused by his father,” says Fr. Andrés’ statement, in which he indicated that he “had never made these facts public out of respect for the privacy that Raúl himself requested of me on various occasions.” “I was ignorant of the fact that our conversations had been recorded by Raúl. It surprises and offends me, especially since Raúl himself had asked for complete reserve and discretion regarding the topic,” wrote Fr. Andrés. Raúl González ceased all personal contact with Fr. Andrés in February of 2009. Subscriber comments:
Published by: jjh
tallahassee fl usa 07/07/2010 07:17 PM EST
Not again...and again...and again.
What a sad commentary. Some priests do obey their vows. Let priests marry and live their life in a normal way. This is permitted outside the Latin Rite.
Published by: Alphonso
San Antonio, Texas USA 05/04/2010 09:19 AM EST
The infallible HOLY FATHER, God's only true representative on Earth has taken this matter under full control. Everyone else should close their big mouths and let the POPE handle this as only He, acting directly as GOD's officer can. The woman in this story should count herself blessed that a SAINT would spend his time with her. Everyone who doubts the POPE and the LEGION is a secularist who should stop pretending to be a CATHOLIC.
Published by: mal
Chicago 04/02/2010 11:57 PM EST
I couldn't agree more with Manuel C. of Nuevo Leon on all accounts particularly in bringing to justice all of Maciels acomplices and those in authority who blocked attempts at investigations. Serious (re)consideration ought to be given to advancing the canonization of a pope who at best was blind to this reality or who at worst knowingly refused to act against this sinful and criminal man. Perhaps other investigations might be aimed at prelates who allegedly attempted to silence clergy who pursued investigations of Maciel from Mexico City to the Vatican.
Published by: Phyllis
Ft Wayne, IN. USA 03/29/2010 09:35 PM EST
A relative of mine has recently joined The Legionaires of Christ and will become an ordained Priest. Please do not punish these young men. Perhaps you could interview them to get their views. Above all trust in God in all things.
Published by: Guy Richards
Athol, Ma USA 03/15/2010 12:38 PM EST
The Boston Globe broke the news about the sexual abuse of children in the Catholic church. It was not only the abuse that shocked people, but the cover-up of the abuse by the leaders in
the church. The offending priests were often transferred to other parishes where the abuse continued. It took the efforts of reporters to expose this shameful conduct.
It will be interesting to see what knowledge Pope John Paul II had of this group when he promoted and supported the founder and the organization. Was it another cover-up? When do the leaders
take responsibility for their "sins?"
Published by: Pamela
Madison, WI 03/13/2010 12:21 PM EST
The Vatican needs to take over this corrupt order and remove those in charge, anything less, and they have permission to continue their evil ways.
Published by: Wendy
Guelph/Ontario/Canada 03/12/2010 12:15 PM EST
I think we should remember that all of this scandal is attached to one name. That is Marcial Maciel, the Legion of Christ has done nothing wrong and has opened their doors for investigation to prove their innocence.
We are not here to judge anyone, that alone will be done in time by God.
Published by: Sam
CT.,USA 03/11/2010 02:15 PM EST
No one knows how many other Legionaires were involved in Maciel's sordid deceptions...or how many young seminarians were perverted by Maciel and others in leadership roles..just close down the Legionaires (some of whom still call Maciel 'our father' and keep his picture hanging in their places) - let the young Priests and seminarians be incorporated into a Papal community where they can be healed and given true formation...the infection of Maciel and his teachings and perversions could be wide spread and hidden...they are not supposed to be recruiting for vocations or for money but they ARE doing it big time...as far as the one who wants $26 million...don't even consider it. Although there were and are many legitmate claims of abuse, some just want to get on board for the money...be discerning and just...pray for guidance and courage...and it will be given.
Published by: Adim
Providence, RI 03/11/2010 02:11 PM EST
Praise be to our Lord Jesus, now and forever more. This is a very painful time for the whole Church (the body of Christ), the Legion of Christ and the alledged family of Fr, Marciel. It is very sad and worrysome, to think that this priest was engaged in this kind of life. I do not condemn him for God alone can do that, but I feel it is a very grave hurt on the churc and those he left behind.
First of all, I hope that A DNA test has been performed, to be certain that all these children are surely from Fr. Marciel. I do not intend to cause a ny hurt, but I believe that in an open and scientifically advanced society like ours, this is very necessary, so that we can be sure of what we are dealing with.
It is also disturbing to hear all the new alegations of incest that are coming up. Now the priest is not hear to respond to them. I call on all of us, as angry and saddened as we may be, to tred with caution, before we fall into error. The whole situation is bad enough, so lets not cause more by the cursing and abusing words that people are using in their comments.
Also if the family asked for money so keep their silence, then this points so something very fishy. Is the seeking of justice the main motivation or just financial gains. Let the truth be told, no matter how painful and let things be addressed properly. No amount of money will cure their pain, if they are truely hurt. I wonder why people enjoy the benefits of crime only to talk of abuse when the benefit is over
Published by: A.Schembri
Malta 03/11/2010 11:26 AM EST
Histroy and that of the Church in particular has proveed that only can judge our neighbor
Published by: John
Alamosa, CO. USA 03/11/2010 10:34 AM EST
Does this shake one's faith? One must see that the Holy Spirit still guides the Mystical Body as Jesus foretold. The Mystical Body--The Kingdom of God--is not synonomous with the Institutional Church. The Inst. Church has seen its demise in the works for many years now and that is the work of the Holy Spirit. Watch Archbp Diarmuid Martin and Card. Sean O'Malley. The Holy Spirit is working in them to free the Kingdom of God which Jesus came to announce. It will take much time and pain. The Inst. Church has painted itself into a corner, declaring infallibility and Tradition as its hallmarks of authenticity. Its fondness for secrecy against all comers including young children is its last line of defence for its claims. These scandals will destroy its claims. The laity instinctively sense this. Do not be confused, Jesus and His Holy Spirit are alive and well in God's Kingdom on earth. Bind your faith to the Trinity, not ecclesiastical abuse of power. That too shall pass.
Published by: Dennis
Columbus 03/11/2010 09:58 AM EST
How does $26 make a serious mortal sin go away? This whole thing requires prayer and repentence, not millions of dollars. This is typical of today's materialistic society...trying to make all things right through money.
Published by: Maggie
vero/fl/USA 03/09/2010 07:05 AM EST
The founder and his writings are the foundation of the order. We now know these were plagarized writings. Why would anyone want to follow a man who so obviously sold his soul. He lived the life he sold his soul for.
Power is the overarching theme, it's branches are the seven deadly sins and the root of it all is the love of money. This is the tree of death. This whole sordid affair wreaks of death. Please disband it. Disburse the monies to the used and abused and truly calumniated. Please my Father's house, do not profit from this. Choose Life.
Published by: Pat
UK 03/08/2010 08:48 AM EST
We now have a woman who previously attempted to blackmail the Legion to the sum of $26m, making amazing claims against Fr. Maciel. I think we should wait till the authenticity of these claims are proved before we make too much judgement. Certainly the Legion are more than correct to view this claim with caution.
Published by: Juan Dalita
Oslo, Norway 03/06/2010 02:54 PM EST
Matthew 23:13-28
Published by: Dr. Madinda
Dar-es salaam Tanzania 03/06/2010 01:22 PM EST
Scandals following the church for sometime now will never destroy it.
This is because it is not the teaching of the church to abuse sexually believers but rather a personal weakness on the part of the priests involved. Even the much talked about the irish scandal has nothing to do with the church . We devoted catholics do understand that the devil has angelic powers and can deceive anybody, look for example the anglican church is in deep trouble for ordaining gay priests and bishops! ironically anglican priests are allowed to mary.
Jesus said the road that lead to heaven is small and full of thorns and not easily passable.
If priests are found on the wide road the church has nothing to do with it because his principle and teachings are well known.
So people should stop pointing fingers at the church everytime there is a sexual scandal
After all who is clean to judge the other?
Dr. Madinda
Published by: Matthew
Sacramento CA 03/06/2010 09:23 AM EST
"Disband the LC" for what? They do an outstanding job of serving the poor and reinvigorating the faith of MILLIONS of people around the world. Fr Marciel led an immoral life but he also started LC and RC which have done so much good. Since Fr Marciel had a double life we should disband it all? What about Toyota? They made some cars that KILL people and no one says "the only possible solution is to disband Toyota"
What really bothers me is that on a Catholic news website there is such a lack a compassion for LC and plenty of ankle biting.
@Alypius - What’s Christ like about their actions? Spend some time with a LC priest or an RC member and then judge what’s Christ-like about their actions.
Published by: EG
Atlanta 03/05/2010 07:13 PM EST
Why do we judge a congregation of priests that has done so much good, just by the acts of one person, even if he was their founder?
Published by: F Arundell
Niantic/CT/USA 03/05/2010 05:19 PM EST
The Body of Christ will pay for the its arrant children. Orders alone does not make men of ill will holy. Pray for his soul and his victims.
Published by: John Dolan
Magnolia,Tx USA 03/05/2010 04:05 PM EST
These never happened in the Pre Vatican
Church. This is a unique situation of
the post vatican 2 church.
Return to the time that salvation
of souls, and excellent example to
the world. Prayer, penance, and fasting
is the only solution to deposed of
the devils, and evil in each of us.
Published by: Kathleen
NY, NY, USA 03/05/2010 02:00 PM EST
In 1970 Ms. Gutierrez already at 19 had a child from a previous “relationship” outside marriage. She freely chose to live with a man representing himself as an elderly widower nearly 3 times her age, who did not mention marriage. She was happy with this, and had 2 more children outside marriage. I do not criticize her moral choices, but they do not indicate that Mr. Maciel victimized her.
Much later she discovered he was 1) an apostate priest; 2) from an organization with a great deal of money.
It is difficult to regard the now 59 year old Ms. Gutierrez as a victim. It is understandable that she desires financial security in her old age, and sees this suit as a way to achieve this. She has my sympathy, if not my approval.
Vatican II began as a great adventure, and ended as a disaster. The Church will survive the scandals of the last 40 years, but the scars made by arrogant, amoral people will remain.
Published by: Alypius
Oshkosh, WI, USA 03/05/2010 01:30 PM EST
At the very least, could someone in power order these people to stop calling themselves the "Legion of Christ?" At the very least? What is Christ-like about their actions? Please!
Published by: Manuel C.
Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, Mexico 03/05/2010 01:28 PM EST
This scandal has gone too far. I'm hoping the final recommendation of Apostolic Visitation to be the dissolution of LC and RC; those priests who are free of any suspicion of being accomplices to Maciel, should be warmly received into other congregations. Maciel is out of reach of any human hand, but everyone who aided him in his deceitful actions should be brought to justice. Dragging the existence of the Legion is only hurting the Church; the Legion should be dissolved or reformed as something completely different. The second option seems less possible.
Published by: Môlsem
Lapwai, ID 03/05/2010 01:11 PM EST
It is time, after the scandals in the US, the continuing Maciel scandals, the Irish scandals, and the German scandals, for the Vatican to acknowledge something pandemic existed in the RC church and to address it firmly on a world-wide basis. It is no surprise that the problem existed, for those with a sexual attraction to children gravitate to occupations providing a cover story for working closely with children, be it Scouting, teaching, athletics, or ministries. The correct understandings of the Church respecting ordination of the sincere clouded the Church's judgment respecting ordination of those who were insincere. The ordained one who seeks ordination in order to have a cover story for access to children for improper purposes, commits horrendous sins both in his insincerity during the sacrament and in his molesting of the children. While punishment on this side of death is appropriate, a greater punishment awaits these offenders on the other side.
All of this does not necessarily render the good things done by such people invalid, but those good things do not excuse the wrongs done under cover of ordination. May these offenders rot in Hell.
Published by: randie
san antonio 03/05/2010 10:13 AM EST
Father Skertchly needs to examine his conscience and make a good confession for the sin of detraction against Raul. This was an astounding move on the part of a priest, to respond to Raul's painful revelation of his sexual abuse by branding him an extortionist. He has shifted the focus from Raul, as incest victim, to the Legion, as victim of extortion attempt. Skertchly has further put RC and LC faithful in the position of violating their charitable stand to "Believe all the good you hear and only the bad you see"
Legally, Skertchly places the Legion in a bad position as well. A letter he himself has written accusing Raul of extortion does not stand as evidence of extortion. On the other hand, depending on libel laws in Mexico, Skertchly may be on shaky ground if he needs to prove his allegation. He has likely placed the Legion in a worse position, if that's possible.
Published by: Jon
Ft Myers 03/05/2010 07:30 AM EST
LC and RC pose as orthodox but are not; it's all a ruse to attract money and power. Consider their newspaper, the National Catholic Register, which endorsed the decision of the Connecticut Bishops to allow Catholic hospitals to give abortifacient contraception to rape victims, and chummed up to abortionist Obama after his election victory. Orthodox? Right.
Published by: Aaron
Ireland 03/05/2010 06:47 AM EST
Who are the real victims here? Raul was sexually abused by his father, Marcial Maciel for EIGHT years.
How dare the Legion react in this way. Not only are they detracting and hurting a long suffering victim but they are creating the very evidence they use to shout extortion:
Fr. Skertchly writes a letter quoting a telephone conversation - we all know that repeating telephone conversations has no value in court - that says that Raul would keep quiet if he gets his inheritance and his compensation.
This is not extortion - he asks for no money for silence, the only money he asks for is his inheritance and compensation.
The Legion writes this letter then uses it as supposed proof of extortion!!! In the same letter they speak of pastoral care of the vicitms and of Raul in particular. Well they have a funny way of showing pastoral concern.
I believe Skertchly, Corcuera, Garza, Sada - these are the true children of maciel.
Published by: hrh
miami, fl, usa 03/05/2010 12:15 AM EST
Just when you thought this sick mess couldn't possibly get any sicker.........
ADD A COMMENT (Your e-mail will NOT be published):
* Thanks for your comments. The number of messages that can be online is limited. Length should not exceed 1500 characters. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages. ADVERTISING |
Latest news:
05:18 am | Vatican prefect encourages Chinese clergy in commitment to unity 05:16 am | Citing new memo, Senators urge HHS to restrict abortion funding in high-risk pools 03:27 am | Anglican cleric apologizes for giving communion to dog 12:54 am | Boston archdiocese asks for lay participation in Catholics Come Home campaign 10:06 pm | Judge rules against Christian banned from Eastern Michigan counseling program Related news :
Legionary priest urges movement to 'assume consequences' and correct mistakes Open letter reignites debate within Legionaries of Christ Vatican daily publishes article on priesthood by Legionaries of Christ vicar Get CNA News on your email:
Resources
|
ADVERTISING
Place your ad here |
||||||
|
||||||||

