Young Catholics not turning to sanctity of life and marriage as voting issues, poll finds
Imprimir Incrementar tamaño de fuente Disminuir tamaño de fuente

.- A new poll of Americans ages 18-34 has surveyed the faith, politics, and issue positions of young adults before the 2008 election. The poll claims about 60 percent of younger self-identified Catholics say abortion should be legal in all or most cases, while 44 percent reportedly support same-sex marriage, a number which rises to 64 percent when religious liberty protections are emphasized.

The claims come from the Faith in Public Life’s “The Faith and American Politics Survey,” which was conducted by Public Religion Research between August 28 and September 19. Polling 2,000 American adults and an over sample of 1,250 younger adults, its methods included both land line and cell phone interviews.

Overall, 44 percent of Catholics said abortion should be illegal in all or most cases, while 54 percent said it should not. About 61 percent of young Catholics reported it was not a very important voting issue, compared to 56 percent of Catholics 35 years and older.

As a whole, 30 percent of Catholics agreed that “gay couples should be allowed to marry,” rising to 47 percent when the question is framed by the insistence that “no church or congregation would be required to perform marriages for gay couples.”

Only 26 percent of young Catholics said they favored no legal recognition for same-sex couples, compared to 32 percent of those 35 years old and up. About 22 percent of young Catholics considered it a very important voting issue, compared with 27 percent of those 35 and older.

Respondents were also asked what they heard talked about in church. Among all Catholics, 90 percent said they have heard about hunger and poverty while 78 percent claimed to have heard about abortion and 37 percent claimed to have heard about homosexuality. About 33 percent said they heard about immigration while 58 percent said they had heard about the war in Iraq and 54 percent said they heard about the environment at church.

On the issue of torture, about 54 percent of Catholic survey respondents initially reported they opposed torture. When framed by the survey’s “Golden Rule” argument against torture, which states “the U.S. government should not use methods against our enemies that we would not want used on American soldiers,” this opposition rose to 62 percent.

Turning to the presidential election, the poll shows overall voters who attend religious services once or twice a month support Obama at a rate of 60 percent. The same group showed 49 percent support for John Kerry in 2004. Catholics aged 35 and older are split between McCain and Obama 46 percent to 44 percent, but Obama leads McCain among younger Catholics 55 to 40 percent.

Overall, 49 percent of voters think Obama is friendly towards religion, while only 45 percent say the same of McCain.

Commentators on the poll tried to depict its results as showing the end of the “culture wars.”

“Younger Americans, including younger Americans of faith, are not the culture war generation,” claimed said Dr. Robert Jones, President of Public Religion Research and lead analyst of the poll. In his view, they are “bridging the divides that entrenched their elders and ushering in an era of consensus in which the common good trumps the clash of ideologies.”

Katie Paris, Director of Communications Strategy at Faith in Public Life, agreed.

“Expect to see the dividing lines of the culture wars continue to fade,” she asserted.

Kristin Williams of the Faith in Public Life Institute provided CNA with Dr. Robert Jones’ more detailed statistical breakdowns of the Catholic respondents.

Of Catholics ages 18-34, 28 percent reported attending church once a week, while 22 percent said they attend once or twice a month. Another 27 percent reported attending a few times a year, while 17 percent said they seldom or never attend church. Six percent reported attending church more than once a week.

Among all registered voters the church attendance rate was somewhat different with 18 percent reporting that they attend religious services more than once a week and 27 percent saying they attend once a week. About 15 percent attended once or twice a month, 16 percent attended a few times each year, while 23 percent seldom or never attend services.

Among all age ranges of Catholic registered voters, 10 percent reported attending religious services more than once a week while 36 percent reported attending once a week. Eighteen percent of Catholics reported attending once or twice a month, while equal percentages each reported attending a few times a year or seldom or never.

Imprimir Incrementar tamaño de fuente Disminuir tamaño de fuente
Subscriber comments:
Published by: Teacher
Toronto Ontario Canada 10/15/2008 01:23 PM EST
Social Justice leaving behind Christianity in the dust, is how I'd classify the "Faith in Public Life" organization.

Way far away even from Canada, I see this is a Democratic Party'ish kind of website.

This type, wanders the halls of Catholic education in Canada whispering the same ideas to our youngest children. In Canada join the parent council's of Catholic Schools (Catholics can, even if you don't have children in the school )- ask questions - especially about religious education & fundraising - ask to see the material being used. Suggest changes.

The usual rhetoric how good jobs are more important than even the right to life. It puzzles me that if you don't get the chance to live -how are you going to take up the call for social justice?
Published by: Michael Brook
Newark/DE/USA 10/12/2008 02:22 PM EST
Trouble for McCain and Palin. Kudos to the Catholics of America.
Published by: Rev. Matthew Chadwick
Philadelphia, PA USA 10/10/2008 07:24 PM EST
These polls must include a direct comparison between Church attendance and the acceptance of Church teaching. Catholics, young or old, who do not attend Mass EACH Sunday and Holy day hold the same views as the typical American pagan, that is a person who says he believes in God, but Faith is NOT THE MOST IMPORTANT aspect of his life and lives from Monday to Saturday like a pagan.
Those who practice their Faith SERIOUSLY are overwhelmingly PRO-LIFE!
Published by: Gabriel Austin
Los Alamos NM USA 10/10/2008 01:26 PM EST
FAITH IN PUBLIC LIFE is headed by a Presbyterian lady minister.
Published by: Ronald P. Cuenod
Houston, TX, USA 10/10/2008 10:33 AM EST
That such a large percentage of young Catholics would support anti-Catholic issues reveals poor Catholic foundation and that fault lies with parents and Bishops that don't demand principled education.
Published by: Miguel Perez-Santalla
Mountainside, NJ 10/10/2008 09:56 AM EST
I don't believe them. I think they are skewing the numbers to manipulate believers.
Published by: Dai Yoshida
Jackson, MI 10/10/2008 07:43 AM EST
If a Mormon seldom or never attended religious service, he will not be counted in a survey of Mormons. Yet, non-practicing Catholic will call themselves Catholics and are counted in a Catholic survey to skew the result. Amazing. I guaranty you if you conducted the same survey in the Church parking lot on Sunday morning you will get a decidedly different result.
Published by: sheila
Millis, MA 10/09/2008 10:25 PM EST
You can not be Pro choice and Catholic. That is the simple truth.
Published by: mary
Kansas City 10/09/2008 06:40 PM EST
Well, this is one eighteen-year-old Catholic that WILL be voting pro-life! Most of my friends will be too, and we're trying to educate our Catholic and Christian friends about voting pro-life. (And against gay marriage!)
Published by: Paul C
germantown, MD, USA 10/09/2008 06:40 PM EST
Why don't you state what "Faith In Public Life" says in its own website when you type in "gay" for a search - it's news updates are full of editorials that are pro-gay, anti-conservative, anti-republican in a very mocking and condescending manner.
Published by: Fran B
melbourne flrida 10/09/2008 05:20 PM EST
Its no wonder the united states is losing graces with God.The mentality of americans wanting to kill there unborn is sicking.I pray that there souls will be saved.God help us
Published by: jerry
spokane /wa/ usa 10/09/2008 04:07 PM EST
It was said long ago by some saint or something "What our generation tollerates the next one will embrace. this is true for so many things. phycologist have messed up everything with tollerence. They have made it a religion. I can't believe our college's, but especially our phyc departments with the whole anti-religious attitude...teacher/Dr.s can kuss in class but do not metion God it is just the Underling tone that this is just not done in class or out of class talking with friends...Love the sinner(which I am)hate the sin. this is love not tollerace.
Published by: MAUREEN
u.k. 10/09/2008 03:51 PM EST
I have just returned from holiday in the USA I had the ordeal of attending a young peoples mass in Washington. It an Insult to Jesus Christ the worst mass I have ever been to no wonder the young people have not a clue about the teachings of the Catholic Faith.
Published by: Dan in Calgary
Calgary Alberta Canada 10/09/2008 03:08 PM EST
While accepting gay marriage in society so long as the Church is permitted to abstain may be excusable as a naive "live and let live" philosophy, youths who accept abortion are NOT "Catholic Youth" no matter what they call themselves. And pointing to their involvement in our Church is NOT a success story, because they should not be there unless they change their view.

So much for the post-Vatican II initiative of catering to "youth" while recklessly stripping our Liturgy of all reverence, dignity and meaning, while soft-pedaling Catholic principles. It didn't work! And we elders were made to sacrifice the most beautiful and precious aspects of our lives (a truly meaningful and reverent Latin Liturgy that connected us with our ancestors in faith) for next to nothing.

All is not lost, but severe and immediate change is absolutely necessary.

Dan in Calgary
Published by: Larry Lindgren
Grand Forks,ND, USA 10/09/2008 01:52 PM EST
It's apparent that we need to do some serious catechizing in the Catholic Church.
Published by: Douglas J. Cook
Madison AL 10/09/2008 01:35 PM EST
The result of this poll speaks volumes about the current teachings of "boomer" Catholics. Abortion is NOT a choice but it is a crime against the most vulnerable and innocent in our civilization.

Recently, thank God, some bishops are finally speaking loudly and clearly about the evils of abortion. In this election we are choosing between a man who respects all human life from conception to natural death and a man and his “Catholic” running mate who promote abortion at any time and fully support infanticide during botched abortions.

All bishops as individuals should speak out loud and clear on this!
Published by: Maryellyn Maher
West Chester, PA 10/09/2008 11:22 AM EST
Some one must remind these young Catholics that certain decisions come with serious consequences.
-----------------------
1. Is it true that there are sins that cry out to Heaven?

A. 1. Yes. The Catholic Church teaches that there are 4 Sins that cry out to Heaven.

Q. 2. What are these sins?

A. 2. They are:

Willful murder (See Genesis 4.)

The sin of Sodom (see Genesis 18)

Oppression of the poor (See Exodus 2)

Defrauding laborers of their wages (See James 5)
Published by: Johnnie
Beaumont,Texas,USA 10/09/2008 10:06 AM EST
They are not Catholics,No.They are Liberals. Big difference.Each one of them who promotes their agenda verus the truths of our catholic faith is a heratic,and should not even recieve and profane the body of Christ.
Published by: Jennifer
Madison,Ks 10/09/2008 09:58 AM EST
Unfortunately 40 years of secular and liberal church propaganda have proven Pope Leo correct "Satan has entered the church".
Published by: Brian
Indianapolis, IN, USA 10/09/2008 09:05 AM EST
Please don't demonize younger Catholics. They're not out to turn the planet into a satanic orgy. They're not burning incense to Karl Marx or Vladimir Lenin or the Frankfurt School. They're not out to establish the New World Order or whatever is the latest object of scorn. Try listening to them. Try viewing reality from their perspective. Aren't they simply trying to do the right thing, however misguided they may be in certain instances? Aren't they trying to go beyond the demonization and fear-mongering? The Culture War is not a simple battle between good and evil, but rather a conflict of human ideologies of traditionalism and liberalism. There IS a difference. Let's not demonize the Other. Let's not spread fear and hatred of the Other. Let's not threaten violence against the Other. That's what Klansmen and Neo-Nazis do in the name of Traditional Morality and Traditional Society and Natural Law. Instead let's dialogue with the Other and gently lead it towards the truth in Jesus Christ.
Published by: Bridget Grimmie
Sicklerville,NJ, United States 10/09/2008 08:46 AM EST
I would love to say that I am surprised by these numbers, but I am not.As the mother of six children, the youngest being 12; I hear from them how people their age are thinking.The current society tries to take God out of the picture in all aspects of our lives.There isn't accountability for our actions.Media and self-interest groups feed our children a bunch of lies.Let's not call a developing child a baby let's call it a blob of tissue;then we can justify whatever we choose to do.Do not teach your children to be responsible for their sexuality, waiting until they are married,feed them images of unbridled sexuality and make it seem appealing.Expose them to all kinds of types of sexuality and make it seem "normal".Desensitization to God's laws.We as Catholic parents can discuss these issues with our children but they still have to go out into the world that we live in. It is very hard for them but with God's help they will continue to fight the good fight, and we as parents must pray without ceasing, for our children and all of the future generations.
Published by: Tim
PA 10/09/2008 08:36 AM EST
This does not surprise me at all. When too many of our Catholic schools and our priests exclude proper instructions on the Catholic faith. Too many Catholic leaders in the US believe it is more important to get along than to create tensions by speaking the truth. If Christ took the same position 2000 years ago there would be no Christain faith.
Published by: Scott Price
Naugatuck, CT 10/09/2008 07:52 AM EST
CNA should advise its readers that Faith in Public Life is a left-leaning organization with a liberal political bias and that this poll is designed to advance their leftist agenda.
Published by: Michele
Centreville 10/09/2008 07:25 AM EST
Indeed, the Catholic Church is becoming smaller with more devoted Catholics. Those believing in abortion have already left the church and don't know it - I guess
Published by: Christian
Frankfort/KY/USA 10/09/2008 06:53 AM EST
Fruits of World (Whirled?) Youth Days, Lifeteen Messes, and the New Religion?
ADD A COMMENT (Your e-mail will NOT be published):
NAME:
CITY/STATE/COUNTRY:
EMAIL:
COMMENT:
 
PLEASE ENTER THE SECURITY CODE DISPLAYED ABOVE:
Chars:
* Thanks for your comments. The number of messages that can be online is limited. Length should not exceed 1500 characters. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages.
ADVERTISING
Place your ad here
Resources:
Columns:
News:
Documents:
Tools:
ACI Group:
ACI Prensa