Priest accused of sex abuse dismissed from Augustinians over ‘disagreement’ with superior

CNA Staff, May 16, 2025 / 16:11 pm

A priest who was accused multiple times of sex abuse, including possession of child pornography, has been dismissed from the Order of St. Augustine reportedly after a lengthy “disagreement” with the order.

Father Richard McGrath was allegedly barred from the order “following a prolonged period of disagreement with his direct superior,” according to Michael Airdo, an attorney who has represented the Augustinians in the past. 

The dismissal reportedly happened in December 2024, according to Airdo. The Chicago Sun-Times reported on the controversy on Thursday.

The Sun-Times did not say what prompted its Thursday report if the dismissal happened in December. The Midwest Augustinians did not respond to a request for comment on Friday, including whether or not they knew the whereabouts of McGrath. Airdo also did not immediately respond to an emailed request for comment. 

McGrath was previously accused of sexual abuse by Robert Krankvich, a former student of Providence High School in New Lenox near Chicago. The priest, formerly the principal of the school, allegedly raped Krankvich multiple times, according to Krankvich’s attorneys. 

The former student’s civil lawsuit was ultimately settled for $2 million before it went to trial. 

McGrath was also investigated over allegations that he possessed child pornography on his phone. Police investigated those claims but ultimately did not bring charges; McGrath refused to hand over the phone to police, and the device reportedly went missing shortly thereafter. 

The Midwestern Augustinians have published a list of past members with “an established allegation of sexual abuse with a minor.” The list, which identifies five past members by name, was last updated in May 2024; McGrath is not on it. 

“In determining whether an allegation of sexual abuse of a minor is established, the province adheres to the canonical standard of moral certitude, meaning that the provincial recognizes that the contrary (that the allegation is false) may be possible, but is highly unlikely or so improbable, that the provincial has no substantive fear that the allegation is false,” the list says. 

Though it is not clear why specifically McGrath was removed from the Augustinians, the Sun-Times reported that at some point the priest “stopped listening to Church officials about where to live.”

During proceedings over Krankvich’s allegations, McGrath was reportedly asked if he knew “why the Augustinians [were] trying to expel” him.

“Because I left on my own, without their approval,” McGrath replied.

Prior to his pontificate, Pope Leo XIV previously served as prior provincial for the Midwestern Augustinian province, and later as prior general of the entire Augustinian order.

Airdo said in a statement to the Sun-Times that the pope — then-Bishop Robert Prevost — was serving in Peru during disputes over where McGrath lived. The future pope “had no responsibility for any Augustinians” and no oversight of McGrath’s living arrangements, the lawyer said.