Against this political setting, a mysterious hero emerges, known only as V. Natalie Portman's character, Evey, encounters him plotting to bomb Parliament in order to restore justice to England. When she becomes a prisoner in his house, the two unconvincingly fall for one another, even though she cannot see his face and he cannot remember his own identity.
Initially, this film fascinated me with its elaborate plot and creative setting. I even admired its political relevance, until it became clear that V for Vendetta is a deliberate attack on the Church's defense of morality. Not only is Christianity aligned with a brutal dictatorship, this theocracy is responsible for systematically murdering homosexuals throughout England. The film's only Catholic figure is a bishop openly indulging his pedophilia, unfortunately a character type which is becoming a familiar cliché in contemporary cinema. As Catholic teaching on sexual morality is misrepresented as violence in yet another film, we are reminded of the constant need to avoid this stereotype by exercising kindness and charity when proclaiming the truth.
I could continue to list the dozens of reason why I do not recommend that anyone invest money or time into V for Vendetta, but I will instead allow the film to speak for itself. Near the ending, Evey shares a tender kiss with V, who is wearing, as always, a profoundly disturbing and necessarily unresponsive Guy Fawkes mask. This image represents in two words my impression of the entire film: wasted effort.
Pride & Prejudice (2005)
This most recent film adaptation of a Jane Austen classic took me by surprise in nearly every way. Directed by newcomer Joe Wright, Pride & Prejudice is astounding for its technical perfection, its unique style, its intelligent humor, and its believable romance.
The story relates the Bennet family's attempts to marry off their five daughters, centering on Elizabeth, played by Kiera Knightley. She is an honest, intelligent, and courageous woman who desires and expects real happiness, defying the frivolity of the world around her. Her love-hate relationship with the enigmatic Mr. Darcy motivates the narrative. This is authentic romance: attraction, perplexity, tenderness, forgiveness, virtue.
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
At Catholic News Agency, our team is committed to reporting the truth with courage, integrity, and fidelity to our faith. We provide news about the Church and the world, as seen through the teachings of the Catholic Church. When you subscribe to the CNA UPDATE, we'll send you a daily email with links to the news you need and, occasionally, breaking news.
As part of this free service you may receive occasional offers from us at EWTN News and EWTN. We won't rent or sell your information, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
While not an Austen expert, I consider myself quite a fan, and this adaptation captures both her genuine love of romance and her wry critique of society's ridiculous pretenses. Wright communicates volumes in the details of his images, as Austen does in her prose. In this environment, a simple curtsy can speak louder than many words, conveying cold civility, romantic tension, or thinly veiled disdain, all in the subtlety of the gesture.
There is no audience to which I cannot recommend this delightfully mature PG-rated movie. Younger audiences will likely fail to appreciate its wit and art, but at the very least there should be nothing offensive in its content. In order to fully appreciate the brilliance of Pride & Prejudice, I suggest paying attention to every camera movement, every costume, every glance and every line of dialogue. Like Austen's writing, the beauty and meaning of this film lies in its details.