According to the Washington Post, hospital officials defended Sr. McBride’s actions. At the same time, she has been reassigned from her job as vice president of mission integration at the hospital.
Last week Catholic Healthcare West sent to Bishop Olmsted a letter signed by board chairwoman Sr. Judith Carle and President and CEO Lloyd Dean. Seeking clarification on the directives, the letter agreed that pregnancy is “not a pathology” in a healthy mother but it claimed the case of the abortion was different because of the nearly certain risk of death for the mother.
"If there had been a way to save the pregnancy and still prevent the death of the mother, we would have done it," the letter said, according to the Arizona Republic. "We are convinced there was not."
Seeking comment, CNA contacted John Brehany, executive director and ethicist of the Catholic Medical Association.
In a Monday e-mail, he expressed “sadness” that the life of the unborn child was taken and said he regrets that the hospital did not work with the bishop and the diocese “more proactively” to avoid the situation.
Brehany said Bishop Olmsted drew attention to the “consistent and solemn teaching of the Church that one can never intentionally do evil to achieve a good end or result.” This includes never choosing an action “whose intent and direct effect is to end the life of an unborn child.
Noting “some very complicated diseases and health care conditions” which affect pregnant women, he said the Church has recognized some cases like uterine cancer in which effective treatment results in the death of the unborn child.
“To deal with these hard cases, a four-step process of moral analysis, called the principle of double effect, has been developed. Working through this process helps us to ensure that neither the intent nor the direct effect of the action proposed is morally evil,” Brehany explained.
In the case of uterine cancer treatment, the intent is to treat a dangerous disease. The means of the action, removing the mother’s diseased organ, does not directly target or kill the unborn child, “nor is the death of the unborn child the means by which the mother's life is saved.”
Judging from descriptions he had read in the press, Brehany added “it appears that teachings of the Church and this process were not appropriately followed.”
“While the mother suffered from a serious disease, it seems it was the intent of the health care providers to end the life of the child. And, the means chosen to promote the health of the woman was to abort a viable pregnancy.”
(Story continues below)
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
At Catholic News Agency, our team is committed to reporting the truth with courage, integrity, and fidelity to our faith. We provide news about the Church and the world, as seen through the teachings of the Catholic Church. When you subscribe to the CNA UPDATE, we'll send you a daily email with links to the news you need and, occasionally, breaking news.
As part of this free service you may receive occasional offers from us at EWTN News and EWTN. We won't rent or sell your information, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Brehany also thought Catholic moral principles were “clear” in the case and the abortion was not consistent with Catholic morals.
Acknowledging “hard cases” which moral theologians struggle to understand, he said he was not sure the Phoenix case rises to such a level of difficulty.
CNA asked Brehany what people should understand about Catholic ethics in this case.
“The Church is motivated by sincere love for all human persons in need. In this case, there were two patients -- mother and child. Both are human beings and both are worthy of our best efforts in medicine.
“Many times in life it is easier to focus on some people and to avoid or overlook the needs of others,” he warned. “The respect for life that still undergirds our Western culture has been the source of many positive developments in technology and medical practice that have saved countless lives.”
“The most important things people can do are to choose morally good actions and avoid morally evil actions. There are many tragedies in life. We cannot always prevent bad things from happening to people.