But Thomas could not corroborate Couzens' account for her article. His charges are denied both by the priest in question, and by the unidentified “fourth altar boy” Couzens says was abused along with him.
In the series' final part, Thomas devotes five sentences to the response of the “fourth altar boy” in Couzens' account, whose disagreement she also mentions briefly in the series' first installment.
That man, who was a close friend of one of the two deceased boys, said he did not “remember anything like” the story about Msgr. O'Brien.
“That just doesn't sound right … I have no memories of that,” the man told Thomas.
Msgr. O'Brien, who retired in 2002, also told Thomas there was “just no truth to any of these things.”
Thomas, however, presented Couzens as an abuse survivor. He was portrayed as making the “wrenching” decision to reveal “the altar boys' secret” to surviving family members of one boy in the group who committed suicide.
Professor Thorn, a member of the Catholic Press Association who has worked with the U.S. bishops' communications committee, said Thomas sacrificed fairness and balance in her handling of the case.
“There's literal adherence to avoiding libel,” Thorn observed, “but the overall cast of the story implies guilt.”
He said Thomas framed the story in a way that “implies that 'what the priest did' caused Brian to commit suicide, 'what the priest did' caused this and that.”
“While 'allegedly is in there, and so it's not technically libelous, the overall cast of the story is prejudicial.”
Thorn noted that the story's title – “The altar boys' secret” – assumes or implies that abuse took place, despite the denial by Couzens' fellow surviving altar server.
Catholic League President Bill Donohue blasted Thomas' reporting in a Dec. 6 statement, saying “responsible newspapers never run stories about alleged wrongdoing unless they can be corroborated.”
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
At Catholic News Agency, our team is committed to reporting the truth with courage, integrity, and fidelity to our faith. We provide news about the Church and the world, as seen through the teachings of the Catholic Church. When you subscribe to the CNA UPDATE, we'll send you a daily email with links to the news you need and, occasionally, breaking news.
As part of this free service you may receive occasional offers from us at EWTN News and EWTN. We won't rent or sell your information, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Donohue also called attention to an allegation against Couzens himself – which Thomas failed to mention, while detailing various claims about Msgr. O'Brien.
“Thomas never told readers that on the night Mark Trader was murdered about a dozen years ago, Couzens got into a fight with him over a botched drug deal,” Donohue stated.
“Although another man was convicted, on appeal it was alleged that Couzens and two other men had 'motive to commit the murder and the opportunity to do so.' This is public record, so why the cover up?”
Donohue also criticized the Star's editorial board for its praise of Couzens in a Dec. 8 column.
“Why is Couzens’ story deemed believable, and the one who says it never happened is ignored?” he asked. “Why hasn’t the Star released the name of the person who says the whole story is bogus?”
The Star, Donohue said, “needs to explain why it thinks that it is possible for a person who was allegedly abused several times to have no recollection of it.”