With Cardinal Dolan warning that "we get burned if we rush documents," the bishops ultimately rejected the document, while also noting that some other type of statement could still be proposed with a clear consensus on what the bishops expect.
A document entitled "Preaching the Mystery of Faith: the Sunday Homily" was accepted by the bishops in an effort to renew and revitalize preaching during the Mass. Homilies must always be a Christ-centered "summons to conversion," presented with love an offering the truths of the faith, it said.
"The ultimate goal of proclaiming the Gospel is to lead people into a loving and intimate relationship with the Lord," the document explained.
The bishops also approved a short document inviting all Catholics to participate regularly in the Sacrament of Reconciliation, particularly during the Lenten season.
The document draws the connection between Penance and the New Evangelization and expresses the Church's eagerness to welcome those who have been away from confession for a significant length of time, as well as those who struggle with hesitation or uncertainty about the sacrament.
During the meeting, the bishops also approved their 2013 budget and heard reports on conference work in the areas of cultural diversity, national collections and Haiti earthquake relief efforts.
A new national collection for the Archdiocese for the Military Services was approved, as well as creating new staff positions in the National Religious Retirement Office and the Subcommittee on Native American Affairs.
They also passed a strategic plan for 2013-2016, which is centered on the New Evangelization and emphasizes faith, worship and witness. The plan includes detailed areas of focus for each year, covering topics such as marriage and family life, sacraments, faith in the public square, migration, cultural diversity and respect for life.
A measure to add the optional memorial of Blessed Francis Xavier Seelos to the U.S. liturgical calendar also received approval from the bishops.
Archbishop Thomas J. Rodi of Mobile, Ala., said that Fr. Seelos holds "contemporary significance" because he was "remarkable in his pastoral zeal" and "came to serve this country because of the need."
"(T)hat can be a source of encouragement to our seminarians and our priests who come to us from other countries," he observed.
(Story continues below)
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
Discussion of the HHS contraception mandate also came up during the second day of the meeting, with Cardinal Dolan explaining that the conference remains committed to its principles, even as the mandate's Aug. 2013 implementation date for religious organizations draws closer.
"Right now I can tell you, the only thing we're certainly prepared to do is not give in, not violate our consciences, and not obey what we consider to be something immoral," he said at a press conference, adding that this conviction "would have an enthusiastic unity among the bishops."
Throughout different dioceses, bishops are currently talking to people who work in charity, health care and education in order "to see what options are open to us," he explained.
"No door is closed, except the door to capitulation," he said.