Ivereigh delivered a talk on how to successfully defend the faith in the modern world and answered questions from pilgrims at World Youth Day in Rio de Janeiro on July 24. He was joined by Alejandro Bermudez, executive director of Catholic News Agency, who added suggestions on how to apply these principles to modern methods of social media.
The event, sponsored by CNA and Catholic Voices USA, was held in both English and Spanish and drew an international crowd of young people.
Ivereigh, who has been a journalist for years, rejected the portrayal of the media as anti-Catholic. Rather, he said, media outlets reflect the frame of modern society, which is their audience.
To be successful, the New Evangelization requires a new apologetics that understands these “frames” of our society, he explained.
Developed in 2010, Catholic Voices helps the faithful recognize modern frames and offer alternative frames that better explain the truths of the Catholic faith.
The first step in doing this is understanding the contemporary frame, how the Church is being seen, Ivereigh said. Then, Catholics must work to understand the value behind the criticism of the Church, which “often comes from a distorted Christian perspective.” From there, they can identify with that value as they begin their answer to the question being posed.
Ivereigh warned against the common attitudes of anger, defensiveness and naiveté, which cause problems for those trying to explain the faith to others.
“When you're angry, that's the only thing people see and the only thing people hear,” he said, explaining that people will notice your anger and miss your message.
In addition, we are not able to “propose to our society the reasons for believing what we believe” when we are stuck in a defensive mode, he said. And those who are naive and fail to “understand the frames that our society puts on the Church” will not be able to step outside the frame and offer a new perspective, delivering a message that needs to be heard in an understandable way.
Ivereigh also shared helpful principles in defending the faith, such as being positive and compassionate, focusing on witnessing rather than winning a debate, speaking from experience, telling stories and seeking to shed light, not heat.
Bermudez then offered tips to apply these principles to the world of social media.
“The principles that are very successful when we deal with media are also very useful when we deal with our families” and other parties or gatherings, he said. However there are additional dimensions - such as space limits and anonymity - that we must take into account when we are dealing with the internet and social media.
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
At Catholic News Agency, our team is committed to reporting the truth with courage, integrity, and fidelity to our faith. We provide news about the Church and the world, as seen through the teachings of the Catholic Church. When you subscribe to the CNA UPDATE, we'll send you a daily email with links to the news you need and, occasionally, breaking news.
As part of this free service you may receive occasional offers from us at EWTN News and EWTN. We won't rent or sell your information, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
One critical challenge in the world of social media is determining when to engage in a discussion and when to avoid it, Bermudez explained.
He noted that Ivereigh's guidelines for dialogue assume “a desire of some kind to engage in a conversation, even if the starting point is aggressive.”
But online, people “who are usually isolated in their hatred of the Catholic Church” become “like packs” of wolves, acting as internet “trolls” who pick fights and upset people with insulting comments.
Sometimes, he suggested, these internet trolls should be engaged, as a means to address the wider audience that is reading the posts. But many times, they should simply be ignored.
“Without that basic minimum interest, any discussion is just a waste of time” and should be avoided, he said.
Bermudez urged Catholics not to be intimated by trolls who seem to dominate social media discussions.