"And so I just looked at her and I said, 'Doctor, I was told there was no hope'," she told CNA. She said learning her son would likely survive his birth sent her into "a lot of shock" and that the rest of that day was a blur.
One thing Michelle clearly remembers, however, is being asked by her doctor what she would name her baby. Until that day, she and her husband had planned to name the baby Benedict, and had been referring to him as "Baby Ben." But when she heard that her child had been healed, Michelle knew he had to be named Michael, in honor of McGivney.
"I just remember weeping and saying, 'His name is Michael,'" said Michelle. "And we never called him Ben after that."
On May 27, 2020, Pope Francis confirmed what the Schachles already knew: they had witnessed a miracle. After extensive medical examination, the unexplained healing of Michael was decreed a miracle that arose through the intercession of Fr. McGivney.
As a result of that miracle, McGivney will be beatified, and referred to as Bl. Michael McGivney.
The Schachles told CNA it had crossed their minds that their prayer could lead to the miracle needed to advance Fr. McGivney's cause for canonization, but that was not their specific goal in asking for his intercession.
"I remember praying the whole, the entire trip (to Fatima), 'let Michael be the miracle,' but like in my heart of hearts, that meant he would live," Michelle explained to CNA. "And I never thought beyond him living...I only wanted him to live."
Daniel told CNA that he remembered thinking, "There's gotta be a baby (who) survives this at some point. Why can't it be ours?" along with "You know, Fr. McGivney needs a miracle. Why can't it be Michael?"
During the investigation into Michael's healing from fetal hydrops, the Schachles were repeatedly asked why they did not pray for Michael's healing from Down syndrome as well. They explained that they viewed a child with Down syndrome as a "blessing" to their family, and that they were only concerned about him being born alive.
Despite the miraculous healing from fetal hydrops, the rest of Michelle's pregnancy did not go entirely according to plan. She delivered her son in an emergency cesarean section after just 31 weeks gestation. Michael weighed only 3 pounds 4 ounces, and spent the first 10 weeks and one day of his life in the hospital.
(Story continues below)
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
Michael was born on May 15, 2015. They call him Mikey.
Even with Michael's early arrival into the world, the hand of providence - and Fr. McGivney - was at work with the Schachle family.
Michael's birthday, May 15, is the anniversary of the chartering of the first Knights of Columbus council. Michelle and McGivney have the same birthday. Both Michael and McGivney were born into families of 13 children - McGivney was the eldest, and Michael the youngest.
Michael was born with a heart defect commonly found in children with Down syndrome, and had heart surgery at just seven weeks old. He had another brush with death at six months old, when he came down with a respiratory illness that landed him in the hospital for six weeks.
But today, Michael is a happy and active five-year-old. He has no conditions related to his prematurity or fetal hydrops, and, by his family's account, he's thriving.