The bishop added that he had reflected prayerfully on whether to expend diocesan funds to pursue the possibility of criminal prosecution.
"My goal is some semblance of justice, reparation, and at least spiritual restitution," Vasa wrote.
"I am still very angry and it is almost impossible to set that anger aside and mercifully discern the path forward. I have asked myself repeatedly what 'good' could come from Father Oscar's prosecution and possible imprisonment. What does 'justice' look like in this particular case?"
Vasa noted that possible prosecution could be a deterrent to future theft, but noted that canonical penalties could serve the same purpose. He added that the priest's "public exposure...is certainly a punishment which sends a strong message."
"It may happen that the individual parishes involved may desire to file charges and pursue prosecution. I could not oppose such an action. It is the parish's right to do so. I would however advocate for mercy," the bishop wrote.
"I have seriously considered this matter from a variety of perspectives but that does not mean that I am convinced that I am right," Vasa added.
"I know and fully understand that Father Oscar's actions have only indirectly touched me. Others have been more strongly affected, either directly or indirectly. I am aware that you, my brothers in the priesthood, have felt this theft as a violation of fraternity and a betrayal of both trust and friendship. I cannot speak for your ability, desire, or will to forgive. I can only acknowledge that I am aware of these feelings."
"Other individuals have been betrayed as well; mostly the lay faithful. Our laity have been asked so often to understand and forgive and I can assure you that I take my responsibility to speak on behalf of the Church, which is all of us, most seriously. I speak in the name of the Church but the individual parishes where Father Oscar has served have a voice as well. I do not envision that any individual parish will seek to pursue criminal prosecution but I fully understand the hurt and anger which undoubtedly will be stirred up in light of this theft and betrayal," the bishop wrote.
"I ask you to try to turn this moment from one of hurt and anger to a desire for healing, compassion and ultimately forgiveness. I am not negating the seriousness of the crime, I am suggesting a way forward which is more fully consistent with a good and merciful God."